Youths say no to Pentagon wars
Recruiters pushed out of many schools
Published Mar 30, 2005 11:07 AM
Young people’s passive resistance to
the Iraq occupation is driving Army recruiters into early retirement, depression
and thoughts of suicide. In addition, active resistance is growing at all
levels, from pickets at recruitment centers to troops refusing orders to Iraq.
Individual military resisters are becoming spokespersons and role models for
The Pentagon faces a serious dilemma: either retreat from
Washington’s global offensive or consider bringing back military
conscription—the hated draft.
It fears such a step because a new
draft would bring millions of youth into political life. A movement to fight
draft reinstatement is already underway, with actions planned March 31 and a
conference on April 16.
News of this growing struggle has hit the media
since the March 19 protests marking the second anniversary of the invasion of
Iraq. Reports from Fayetteville, N.C., say that 20 active-duty GIs joined the
protest there March 19. (GI Special, March 25) The resistance is beginning to
reach new layers of the population every day.
The hottest point involves
military recruiting. A March 27 article in the New York Times was entitled,
“For Army recruiters, a hard toll for a hard sell.”
are notorious for exaggerating the benefits and options of enlisting in order to
reach their quotas. Now, no matter what the recruiters promise, young people and
their families are saying “No.” Caught between this hostility and
the Pentagon’s orders to lure in youths, the recruiters are on the verge
of a “nervous breakdown,” says the article.
One lifer sergeant
and ex-paratrooper named Latrail Hayes found out last year that a cousin he
recruited returned from Iraq with psychological trauma. Hayes filed for
conscientious objector (CO) status last June, trying to shift out of recruiting
work. His appeal was rejected.
Now Hayes plans to get out in December
after 10 years instead of staying for 20.
Another recruiter told the Times
reporter that pressure from the brass to meet quotas during the Iraq War has
given him searing back pain and stomach problems, and that he has considered
Even though the military sent out an email asking the recruiters
not to speak to the Times reporter, 10 did. Only a “handful”
defended the military.
According to a March 24 article in the Washington
Post, the Army missed its active-duty recruitment target in February and will do
so again in March and April, and the Marine Corps also failed for January and
Students doing counter-recruiting are complicating the
recruiters’ already futile efforts. In early March students at San
Francisco State College drove military recruiters off campus. On March 5 at City
College in New York, the administration called in security and cops to beat up
counter-recruiters who chanted outside the recruiting office.
Military recruiting relies upon the absence of
worthwhile civilian jobs. To anti-war organizers the “volunteer
army” is based on this economic draft, promising jobs and education to
youths who otherwise face a bleak economic future.
Sgt. Carl Webb joined
the Army Reserves to escape a desperate situation when he was 16 in 1981. Though
he has been an anti-war activist since the 1980s, he rejoined the Texas National
Guard in August of 2001. “Being idealistic didn’t pay the
rent,” Webb said. “I thought at the time it was relatively peaceful
so I took a chance and sold my soul to the devil. It turned out to be very bad
In August of 2004, Webb, needing only one weekend drill to
complete his service, was called by a sergeant in his Texas National Guard
medical unit with the bad news. “She told me I was going to Iraq. I had
been called up, reassigned to a different unit and they are going to
Webb considered his options. He rejected the choice of exile.
With his politics—he would fight a war for liberation, for example in the
Union Army against the Confederacy—he knew applying for CO status would be
Instead, he has chosen to resist by going around the country and
speaking out against the war. Webb now asks other soldiers to “follow my
example and use any means necessary to avoid going to Iraq.”
Officer Third Class Pablo Paredes is in a similar situation as Webb, but is in
military custody. Paredes refused to ship out to Iraq last Dec. 6 from San
Diego. He expected a ruling on his CO application in April. Now he faces a court
The son of immigrants from Latin America, Paredes grew up in the
Bronx and admits he “was ignorant about what was going on in the world. I
thought of the Navy as a nine-to-five arrangement, to get money for education
and training for an electronics job. I never believed I’d be involved in
an occupation,” Paredes said on the radio show “Democracy
Now!” on March 28.
‘I took sides with
The Navy sent him to Japan, and there he learned more
about the world and politics and the role of the U.S. military. “As a
Latino, I got interested in the U.S. role in Latin America. Then I began to feel
a need to take sides with humanity.” Now Paredes is speaking publicly,
when he can, against the war and occupation.
Army Pfc. Jeremy Hinzman took
another of the options open to military resisters. When his paratrooper unit at
Ft. Bragg, N.C., received orders to Iraq, Hinzman left for Canada. On March 24
Canada’s Immigration and Refugee Board ruled against him. For Hinzman, the
war in Iraq is illegal, and if he participates he will be a war
The ruling was expected said Hinz man’s lawyer, Jeffrey
House, but still a disappointment. House said that as many as 100 U.S. troops
who have fled to Canada have been waiting for this ruling before coming forward.
Hinzman will appeal the ruling.
Another of the military resisters, former
Staff Sgt. Camilo Mejía, was released from prison in February after
serving nine months for his refusal to return to Iraq while on leave after five
months on duty there. Like Webb and Paredes, Mejía is speaking at public
meetings and to the media about his decision to refuse duty in
Mejía says he disagreed with the war from the beginning.
“I was very much in disagreement with the war, but I didn’t really
want to make a stand, because I was terrified, because I didn’t want to go
through a court-martial, because I didn’t want to go to jail, because I
was a squad leader in an infantry unit, and I didn’t want my friends to
think I was a coward or a traitor.”
When you’re in Iraq,
“you’re in so much danger. And I guess the survival instinct kicks
in and pretty much all you care about is to get out of there, to get out of
there alive with your comrades.” (“Democracy Now!,” March 28)
Now both his war duty and his prison time are over and Mejía has joined
Webb and Paredes and Hinzman as active spokespersons against the occupation of
‘Resisters deserve support’
perspective on all these levels of resistance, Workers World spoke with Andy
Stapp, the founder of the anti-war American Servicemen’s Union during the
war against Vietnam and one of the key organizers in the military at that
“I think Carl Webb is terrific for what he is doing. Also
Mejía and Paredes and Hinzman. They deserve the support of the entire
movement. The same types of resistance happened during the Vietnam War, when
guys refused to get on their airplanes.
demonstrating, going to Canada, soldiers in Vietnam and stateside refusing duty.
Some even attacked their own officers, some held strikes or mass meetings to
vote out their commanding officers. Some had been drafted, others were
volunteers. Many were Marines. Some first thought the war was just. They went to
Vietnam and learned the truth.
“I saw in the newspapers this
week,” Stapp said, “that the government was bragging that 60 percent
of the troops said they support the war. To me, that means 40 percent are
willing to say they don’t support it. That’s not very good news for
Articles copyright 1995-2012 Workers World.
Verbatim copying and distribution of this entire article is permitted in any medium without royalty provided this notice is preserved.
Workers World, 55 W. 17 St., NY, NY 10011
Email: [email protected]
Subscribe [email protected]
Support independent news DONATE