History shows potential for mass struggle
Congress rejects minimum wage hike
Published Mar 16, 2005 1:15 PM
In one of the more despicable displays of
capitalist cynicism and indifference toward low-wage workers, the U.S. Senate,
accurately known as a “millionaires’ club,” refused in early
March to raise the $5.15-hour minimum wage.
The anti-war and
draft-resistance movements, along with other progressive groups and community
organizations, should be sensitive to the potential for struggle arising from
A look at the history of the battle for a minimum wage can
give insight in this area today.
March 6 was the 75th anniversary of the
unprecedented nationwide protest against unemployment and poverty that brought
over 1 million demonstrators into the streets in 1930. It was a day to
The protest came soon after the October 1929 stock market crash
which led to the Great Depression of the 1930s. It was a militant response to
the 1920s, when empires of wealth arose at the expense of the workers and
oppressed. Under flowing banners emblazoned “Work or Wages,” over
110,000 poor and unemployed workers protested in New York City’s Union
An estimated 100,000 demonstrators gathered in Detroit, over
50,000 in Chicago. A like number filled the streets of Pittsburgh and there were
huge crowds of the unemployed in Milwaukee, Cleveland, Los Angeles, San
Francisco, Denver, Seattle and Philadelphia.
“In New York City, the
rally was attacked by 25,000 cops. Hundreds were beaten to the ground with
nightsticks, trampled by the charge of mounted police. ... A New York World
reporter describing the assault at Union Square told of ... detectives, some
wearing reporters’ cards in hat bands, many wearing no badge, running
wildly through the crowd, screaming as they beat those who looked like
communists ... men with blood streaming down their faces dragged into the
temporary police headquarters and flung down to await the patrol wagons to cart
them away.” (Boyer and Morais, “Labor’s Untold
Working-class history: guide to action
In spite of these vicious, unprovoked attacks that also occurred in
other cities, a new stage in the history of the class struggle was in the
making. It led to revolutionary working-class gains and progressive
legislation—the Social Security Act and National Labor Relations Act,
among many others.
From Unemployment Councils, orga ni zed by communists,
socialists and militant class-conscious workers, Black and white, the Congress
of Industrial Org anization (CIO) ultimately came into existence. Millions of
workers rushed to join, following the general strikes and plant seizures of the
mid-1930s. They fought for union recognition and won unprecedented contracts
from a resistant, anti-union industrial sector of Corporate America. An army of
industrial union workers was born, ready to battle for additional social
In 1938, they won the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA). It lifted
the standard of living of the poorer and most oppressed workers, unprecedented
for those days. Child labor, which had flourished among unscrupulous employers,
was outlawed. The minimum age was 16 for work in most non-farm jobs and 18 for
work in hazardous jobs. For students between 14 and 15, the law allowed maximums
of three hours on a school day, eight hours on a non-school day, or 40 hours in
a non-school week.
A minimum wage was set. Time-and-a-half pay was
mandated for hours over 40, and other benefits and protections. The FLSA was the
result of a decade of class struggle.
Today all these social and economic
gains are under attack.
Since the recession of 2000-2001, real wages have
continued to fall as wages have failed to keep up with inflation. The median
wage for 2004 was $13.62, or $8.47 above the $5.15 minimum wage, which has been
the same since Sept. 1, 1997.
At minimum wage, even at 40 hours per week,
the annual wage is only $10,500—well below the poverty level of over
$16,000 for a family of three.
In a phony debate this year the Democrats
proposed a minimum wage increase in three steps of 70 cents each over the next
26 months, to $7.25. Republicans countered with two steps of 55 cents to $6.25
and with several pro-business provisions designed to increase poverty.
While the Republican proposals were more threatening, the Democratic
provisions, even if they passed, would not slow the impoverishment of the
working poor and the oppressed.
A September 2003 Merrill Lynch report
compared the minimum wage to the rate of growth of CEO’s salaries:
“If the minimum wage, which stood at $3.80 an hour in 1990, had grown at
the same rate as CEO pay, it would have been $21.41, rather than the current
$5.15 an hour.” Whatever the reasons this Wall Street Goliath made this
comparison, it does expose the outrageous gap between rich and poor. And the
2005 figures are even more shameful.
In proposing a piddling increase in
the minimum wage, both the Bush administration and the Democrats are acting from
political expediency. But they may be playing with fire. Putting a few more
bucks in the pocket of the working poor may have been the wiser thing to
Repression breeds resistance!
Over the years, as the
service-oriented sector of the economy surpassed the industrial sector, there
were more suits filed under the FLSA than any other agency of government. There
are reports of child labor abuse, overtime and minimum-wage violations, lack of
health and safety training and on-site injuries due to dangerous working
Today, the FLSA is a sham—an appendage to the
anti-worker, anti-union policies of the Bush administration. Led by Secretary of
Labor Elaine Chao, most of the protective language for the lower paid,
service-oriented working poor is ignored by the agency.
In a survey
entitled “Behind the Kitchen Door: Pervasive Inequality in New York
City’s Thriving Restaurant Industry,” a broad gathering of
academics, community economic development organizations, policy analysts and
policy makers, immigration advocates, worker organizations, unions and industry
employers signed on to an overview of workplace conditions in the New York City
The study provides compelling examples of employer
trespasses against minimum-wage earners. The violations include non-payment for
overtime (almost a majority worked more than eight hours a day). Some worked
more than 50 hours a week and others complained of 60-hour work weeks. Many
reported they were paid below the minimum wage and others claimed management
demanded to share their tips.
They had no union. The overwhelming majority
had no health insurance, no sick leave, no vacation pay, and were forced to work
while sick. Many reported health and safety violations: overheated kit chens,
slippery floors, lack of safety guards on cutting machines and other dangerous
Their complaints ended up in the shred ding machines
and waste baskets of the FLSA. The violations go far beyond the restaurant
industry to other service-oriented workplaces: hotels, supermarkets, fast-food
chains and retail stores, sub-contractors and temp agencies. Wal-Mart, a
frequent violator of the law, operates with impunity.
Drawing on their
bitter experiences, minimum-wage workers, overwhelmingly immigrant,
undocumented, women and youth of color, coming out of high schools and colleges
and those that drop out, may be running out of patience.
There is a large
turnover among these workers, but there will be more stability as jobs become
even more difficult to find. Spontaneous angry protests can break out at any
time, particularly by youth, representing many nationalities in these
The AFL-CIO has the potential to be a catalyst for unorganized
workers. It is critical for the growth of the union movement that union leaders
break out of their morass of debates and begin to build a class-wide,
independent movement to deepen their roots in this important sector of the
Deeds are more eloquent than words. History has confirmed,
especially from the class struggles of the 1930s, that a rising tide lifts all
Articles copyright 1995-2012 Workers World.
Verbatim copying and distribution of this entire article is permitted in any medium without royalty provided this notice is preserved.
Workers World, 55 W. 17 St., NY, NY 10011
Email: [email protected]
Subscribe [email protected]
Support independent news DONATE