Categories: U.S. and Canada

New legal attack on Rasmea Odeh

The following email from the Committee to Stop FBI Repression was released Aug. 5.

Rasmea Odeh

Attorneys representing Palestinian-American icon Rasmea Odeh are pushing back against a new legal attack by federal prosecutors.

In a July 21 filing, Rasmea’s defense team went on record as “strongly opposing” an attempt by prosecutors to subject her to questioning at a “mental examination” prior to an already scheduled Daubert hearing, which itself determines if an expert witness can testify at trial. This is especially important in Rasmea’s case, because the Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals recently ruled that trial Judge Gershwin Drain erred in deciding that expert testimony concerning her mental state was irrelevant to her defense. That error led to Rasmea’s unjust conviction in 2014.

On Nov. 29, Judge Drain will hear arguments as to whether Dr. Mary Fabri’s testimony is scientifically valid and applicable to the facts of the case. Recall that before the 2014 trial, Dr. Fabri, a nationally renowned clinical psychologist who has worked with torture survivors for over 25 years, was prepared to testify about how Rasmea’s Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD), caused by the torture and rape she experienced at the hands of Israeli military interrogators in 1969, affected her answers to questions on complex immigration forms decades later in the U.S.

The move by prosecutors to separately “examine” Rasmea before Judge Drain has even ruled on the admissibility of Dr. Fabri’s testimony is outrageous and meant to intimidate Rasmea. Such an examination is irrelevant as to whether Dr. Fabri’s testimony is reliable and applicable. Nothing asked of Rasmea would change Dr. Fabri’s credentials as an internationally recognized expert on PTSD, or her ability to opine on how Rasmea’s PTSD affected her mental state during any of the dates in question.

Because the government’s request to examine Rasmea is in no way relevant to the admissibility of Dr. Fabri’s testimony, it is obviously designed to aggravate the symptoms of Rasmea’s PTSD and the suffering they cause her. The government knows that it cannot credibly attack Dr. Fabri, so it has instead chosen to harass Rasmea by seeking to subject her to this interrogation.

In the defense filing, Rasmea’s attorneys write that there is a “grave risk that such a fundamentally adversarial interrogation — obviously designed to debunk her earnest PTSD defense — would gravely threaten a serious aggravation of her symptoms and the suffering they cause her.”

The government’s request is also basically a challenge to Rasmea’s story, an attempt to claim that she does not have PTSD and that she did not get brutalized by the Israeli authorities almost 50 years ago. This is a dirty political move by the prosecution, but Rasmea remains steadfast and strong, and will not allow the government to punish her for exercising her constitutional right to assert a meaningful defense. While the prosecution will renew its request to examine Rasmea if Judge Drain orders a new trial, we will continue to oppose such underhanded and transparent scare tactics.

From the very beginning, the Rasmea Defense Committee has pointed out that the legal proceedings against Rasmea are nothing but a pretext to intimidate those who fight hard to realize a free Palestine. Demonstrations in support of her have taken place across the U.S. since her arrest in 2013, and we are again going all out for Detroit on Sept. 22.

We will rally at the courthouse at 231 W. Lafayette Blvd., in downtown Detroit, Mich., on Thursday, Sept. 22, 2016, at 10 a.m. Eastern Time, and then pack the courtroom at 11 a.m., as Judge Drain decides whether to allow the government to “examine” Rasmea.

Continue to support #Justice4Rasmea by donating to the defense, organizing educational events in your communities, and staying in touch through justice4rasmea.org and justice4rasmea@uspcn.org.

We will not rest until the charges are dropped.

a guest author

Share
Published by
a guest author

Recent Posts

In honor of International Workers Day: Hamas calls for week of global solidarity

We call upon the workers of the world to a week of solidarity events with…

April 28, 2024

Student organizations in the Gaza Strip in solidarity with U.S. student Intifada

The following statement was posted on Samidoun Palestinian Political Prisoners Network on April 25, 2024. …

April 28, 2024

SUNY BDS movement stages march on Albany for Palestine

Albany, New York Around 200 students, faculty, and activists from a variety of State University…

April 28, 2024

Final Declaration of the Rome Forum: What Future for Palestine?

The Rome Forum crowned two days of intense work on April 20-21, 2024, with the…

April 28, 2024

German police shut down Palestine Congress in Berlin

By Andrew Johnson An anti-imperialist Palestine Congress “against German complicity in the genocide in Gaza”…

April 26, 2024

Taking protests from the streets to the sea

The following article first appeared on the Resistance News Network, April 22. In two days,…

April 26, 2024