Struggle continues in Benton Harbor, Mich.
Rev. Pinkney wins sentencing reversal
Published Jul 27, 2009 9:48 PM
Benton Harbor community leader Rev. Edward Pinkney has won an appeal of his
revocation of probation sentence which was handed down in June 2008. Pinkney,
the leader of the Black Autonomy Network of Community Organizers (BANCO), was
ordered to prison for three to 10 years after a Berrien County judge ruled that
he had threatened the life of another jurist by quoting scriptures in an
article published in December 2007.
The Michigan Court of Appeals handed down the ruling on July 14. However, the
court rendered a mixed decision when it upheld Rev. Pinkney’s original
conviction by an all-white jury in May 2007. He was charged and convicted of
vote fraud and sentenced to one year in jail and five years’
Rev. Pinkney was placed on a tether in May 2007 and confined to his home for
one year. After the publication of an article in the People’s Tribune
newspaper based in Chicago, he was taken from his home and placed in the
Berrien County Jail in St. Joseph, Mich. At a later hearing he was sentenced to
three to 10 years in prison. Over the course of six months Pinkney was
transferred to eight different correctional facilities throughout the
The American Civil Liberties Union of Michigan took up his appeal of the
revocation of probation sentence on the grounds that this sentence violated his
right to free speech. Michael Steinberg, legal director of the ACLU,
represented Rev. Pinkney in the June 9 Court of Appeals hearing held in Grand
A July 15 statement issued by the ACLU said in part: “In its ruling
today, the Court of Appeals said that the trial court’s probation
condition that prohibited ‘defamatory and demeaning’ communications
“‘To the extent that the prohibition of defamatory and demeaning
behavior impinges on defendant’s first amendment rights,’”
wrote the judges, “‘the prohibition was not proper, as it was not
directly related to defendant’s rehabilitation or to the protection of
“The ACLU of Michigan represented Rev. Edward Pinkney’s first
amendment claims; however, the organization was not involved in the underlying
voter fraud conviction, which was upheld today. Due to this conviction, Rev.
Pinkney’s probation will be reinstated.”
Fighting racism, exploitation
Rev. Pinkney was allowed by the Berrien County courts on July 19 to attend
religious services for the first time in two years. He still remains on
probation for the initial conviction of vote fraud and continues to be
monitored by a tether.
A statement issued by BANCO regarding the Appeals Court’s upholding of
the underlying conviction makes clear: “As for the voter charges, the
Appeals court denied Pinkney a new trial. The decision states that Berrien
County committed 13 errors which were ‘harmless.’ Rev. Pinkney says
that all of the errors were, in fact, harmful.” (bhbanco.blogspot.com,
A letter by K.T. Schmidt, published by BANCO on July 17, expresses outrage over
the theft of lake-front property in Benton Harbor in order to build a golf
course for the elites. Neighboring St. Joseph, the seat of Berrien County where
the courts are located, is a predominantly white city that is a center of
commerce and tourism. Benton Harbor is majority African American and is
afflicted by high unemployment, home foreclosures and poverty.
Schmidt calls for a boycott of St. Joseph in response to the usurpation of
public land located in Jean Klock Park, which is the center of the so-called
Harbor Shores development project that will construct the golf course as well
as expensive housing. The Whirlpool Corporation, which is connected with the
Upton family, is criticized in the letter for its support of the ongoing
exploitation and impoverishment of the majority African-American population in
“The promises made by the original Upton family, the founders of
Whirlpool, have become a distant echo. Their fraternity heir, [Congressperson]
Fred Upton, continues to parade his false face while voting against the
stimulus package, against the environmental bill, against policies that would
benefit the poor. He disguises himself by occasionally working on a program for
children. Most people in his district are fed up with him and he was seriously
challenged in the last election by a last-minute candidate. Only the elite like
him,” Schmidt said.
In addition to the criticism of Whirlpool, Schmidt points to the role of the
state government in perpetuating the national oppression of the people of
Benton Harbor. “The governor of Michigan has lost credibility due to her
allegiance with corporations, her promises to create jobs in Benton Harbor by
buddying up with Whirlpool, and the recent acceptance of the people’s
park land [Jean Klock Park] going to Whirlpool developers.
“No one has been hired from Benton Harbor for this heinous project. No
Benton Harbor resident has been hired despite excessive promises made by the
The people of Benton Harbor, while celebrating the victory of Rev. Pinkney in
having one of his sentences overturned, are continuing to fight for the
elimination of racism and exploitation in Berrien County.
Azikiwe attended the Court of Appeals hearing in Grand Rapids on June 9. He
has traveled to Benton Harbor and St. Joseph on numerous occasions to cover
events there since the Benton Harbor rebellion of 2003.
Articles copyright 1995-2012 Workers World.
Verbatim copying and distribution of this entire article is permitted in any medium without royalty provided this notice is preserved.
Workers World, 55 W. 17 St., NY, NY 10011
Email: [email protected]
Subscribe [email protected]
Support independent news DONATE