A response to Henry Louis Gates Jr.
The Atlantic slave trade & the rise of world capitalism
Published May 13, 2010 9:05 PM
An essay by Harvard Prof. Henry Louis Gates Jr. in the April 23 New York Times
took up the ongoing contentious debate around the demand for reparations for
the centuries of unpaid labor extracted from Africans brought to the United
States as enslaved workers. Gates claims that the demand for reparations is
invalid since there were some Africans who collaborated with European slave
traders in dislocating millions of people from the continent between the 16th
and 19th centuries.
These are not new arguments in relationship to a broader question: the
historical significance of slavery as an economic system in the development of
Western Europe, North America, the Caribbean, Central America and South
America. The denial and refusal to apportion adequate blame to the wealthy
elites of monarchs, merchants, explorers and plantation owners — who not
only orchestrated the Atlantic Slave Trade for centuries but benefited
immensely from the profits gained as a result of the exploitation of African
labor and resources — continues today through academics such as Gates who
seek to negate the seriousness of the unresolved national question in the
A recent debate around the importance of slavery in American history was
sparked by Virginia Gov. Robert McDonnell’s proclamation declaring April
“Confederate Heritage Month.” McDonnell made no mention of slavery
and its role in the state in his initial proclamation. The academic and popular
history of slavery in the United States had been dominated for decades by white
Southerners and those who sympathize with their basic assumptions.
Two major assumptions that guide pro-slavery and Confederate thinking are that
slavery was the natural order of relations between Africans and Europeans and
that traditional African societies were just as culpable as the traffickers and
plantation owners. These assumptions ignore the facts that many African
societies fought for centuries against slavery and colonialism, and that
European merchants, landowners and later industrial capitalists reaped enormous
wealth from imported enslaved African labor and the theft of the
Africans resisted slavery on the continent. They fought slavery on the ships
that transported them to Europe and the Western hemisphere. During the course
of slavery on the plantations, small farms, towns and cities, there was flight
and rebellion against this form of human bondage. The slave rebellions led by
Gabriel, Denmark Vesey, Nat Turner, John Brown and Osborne Anderson are
testament to the self-directed efforts to end this system of human bondage in
Who really benefited from the Atlantic slave trade?
Many historians of the 20th century such as W.E.B. DuBois, Eric Williams,
Walter Rodney and Kwame Nkrumah have documented the impact of the Atlantic
slave trade and colonialism on the growth of industrial capitalism in Western
Europe and North America. Eric Williams in his work “Capitalism and
Slavery” wrote: “Many of the 18th century banks established in
Liverpool and Manchester, the slaving metropolis and the cotton capital
respectively, were directly associated with the triangular trade. Here large
sums were needed for the cotton factories and the canals which improved the
means of communications between the two towns.” (“Capitalism and
Slavery,” p.99, 1943)
Yet when arguments are made that Africans benefited from the continent’s
enslavement any objective observer must ask for evidence. One leading Marxist
historian on Africa, Walter Rodney, wrote in his book “How Europe
Underdeveloped Africa” that “Undoubtedly, with few exceptions such
as Hawkins, European buyers purchased African captives on the coasts of Africa
and the transaction between themselves and Africans was a form of trade.”
(Rodney, p. 95, 1972)
Rodney continued: “It is also true that very often a captive was sold and
resold as he made his way from the interior to the port of embarkation —
and that too was a form of trade. However, on the whole, the process by which
captives were obtained on African soil was not trade at all. It was through
warfare, trickery, banditry, and kidnapping. When one tries to measure the
effect of European slave trading on the African continent, it is essential to
realize that one is measuring the effect of social violence rather than trade
in any normal sense of the word.” (Rodney, p. 95)
Guinean President Ahmed Sekou Toure said in 1962: “The relation between
the degree of destitution of peoples of Africa and the length and nature of the
exploitation they had to endure is evident. Africa remains marked by the crimes
of the slave-traders: up to now, her potentialities are restricted by
under-population.” (Rodney, p. 95)
The legacy of enslavement today
Gates’ essay raises several fundamental questions about not only who is
to blame for the Atlantic Slave Trade and which national and class interests
benefited economically from the system of exploitation but what impact this
legacy has had on contemporary U.S. society. The European slave owners and
capitalists gained tremendous wealth from the exploitation of African labor.
With it the industrial capitalist system was built. In addition, in modern
society the legacy of racial dominance and national oppression is very much a
cornerstone in the continuation of imperialism.
Even today African Americans still suffer the most severe impact of the U.S.
economic crisis with significantly higher rates of unemployment, losses of
homes, pensions, health services and a drastic decline in household wealth. In
the criminal justice system, African Americans disproportionately constitute
the largest percentage of people who are serving prison sentences resulting
from social deprivation and the racist character of the legal system.
Racial profiling by law enforcement is a point of induction for African
Americans and other people of color into the criminal justice system. African
Americans are more likely to be stopped by the police and arrested on spurious
charges. Many others are beaten and even killed during routine traffic stops by
police and in encounters with law-enforcement agents.
Professor Gates was a victim of such practices himself in 2009 when he was
arrested inside his own home in Cambridge, Mass., by local police although he
had identified himself as the homeowner and a leading faculty member at
prestigious Harvard University. Gates was fortunate in his encounter with
Cambridge police. Many African Americans and other people of color in the U.S.
are frequently severely beaten, tortured and even killed in similar uninvited
interactions with law enforcement.
Reparations, national liberation and socialism
Any honest assessment of the social impact of slavery in the U.S. would have to
acknowledge that it was the European-American planters, slave traders and later
capitalists who were the exclusive beneficiaries of the trade in human beings
from Africa. In the 21st century, it is the African people on the continent and
in Western Europe as well as the Americas who are still suffering from national
oppression, neo-colonialism and imperialism.
Every effort on the part of any oppressed African nation-state to exert its
independence and sovereignty has been challenged by the imperialist countries
led principally by the U.S. capitalist class. Consequently, it is necessary to
emphasize not only the role of world capitalism as the system that derived its
strength and power from the slave trade and colonialism but that it is
necessary to replace this system of exploitation with a society where the labor
of the workers and farmers are not extracted for profit but for its equal
distribution to all.
The demand for reparations places emphasis on how the most profitable banks and
corporations gained their wealth through the exploitation of African labor.
Institutions such as JPMorgan Chase & Co. Aetna Insurance Company and many
other corporations have been forced to admit in recent years their role in the
slave system in the United States and internationally.
Yet this admission is inadequate without efforts to correct the historical
damage done to the people who have still not reclaimed their rightful place
within modern society. Only with the overthrow of capitalism and imperialism
and the seizure of the wealth stolen by the capitalists can true reparations be
granted to the African people.
Articles copyright 1995-2012 Workers World.
Verbatim copying and distribution of this entire article is permitted in any medium without royalty provided this notice is preserved.
Workers World, 55 W. 17 St., NY, NY 10011
Support independent news DONATE