Cuba and homosexuality
Change apparent in still photos and motion pictures
Lavender & red, part 102
By
Leslie Feinberg
Published Jun 24, 2007 10:17 PM
Two years into the AIDS epidemic and on the eve of the overturning of the
Soviet Union—Cuba’s primary trading partner—and the East
European bloc of workers’ states, the Cuban Revolution continued to make
great gains in the battle against old, obstinate prejudice against same-sex
love.
Qualitative developments of great import took place in Cuba in the late
1980s.
Leonardo Hechavarría and Marcel Hatch wrote that in 1987, the police were
“forbidden to harass people because of appearance or clothing, largely
benefiting gays.”
A year later, another important change in Cuban law occurred. Pre-revolutionary
legislation against “flaunting homosexuality” in public was
rescinded. That edict had threatened feminine males and masculine females of
all sexualities since its imposition under U.S. neo-colonial rule in the
1930s.
Punishment for homosexual acts had already been formally removed from Cuban law
back in 1979—almost a quarter of a century before the U.S. decriminalized
same-sex love.
Research scholars Lourdes Arguelles and B. Ruby Rich noted, though, that the
1979 legal code “failed to legalize manifestations of homosexual behavior
in the public sphere and left intact anti-gay laws dating to the Cuban Social
Defense Code of 1939.”
Arguelles and Rich, summarizing their research in Cuba in the mid-1980s, made a
very important point about the difference between private and public spheres in
a society building socialism that might not be readily apparent to anyone
living in a capitalist system.
They explained, “As delineated in a Latin American socialist setting,
private space is far wider than in the United States, encompassing virtually
all behavior outside the purview of official sanction or attention, while
approved policy, published texts, and official stances compose the public
sphere.”
They added that “within the private sphere, there are a clear latitude
and range of possibilities for lesbians and gay men that surprise the critical
observer.”
Canadian activist Ian Lumsden quoted a gay émigré living in Toronto,
who stated with regard to gay men that “homosexuals in Cuba find it much
easier to be open and free about conveying sexual desire in the street than
they would in Canada.” (“Cuba and Homosexuality”)
However, in 1988 Cuba took another major step by striking down the
imperialist-era “Public Ostentation Law” against “public
scandal” or “extravagance.”
Revolutionary leadership, mass participation
Cuban society was not changing in some automatic, unconscious way. These
developments—which are both a reflection of the growth of consciousness
and an effort to raise wider, deeper consciousness—are the result of
revolutionary leadership, with widespread popular discussion and debate.
Two years before the old law was rescinded, in 1986, Fidel Castro and the Cuban
Communist Party had initiated a popular campaign, “not simply to rectify
errors committed in the last 10 years,” the Cuban president emphasized,
“or errors committed throughout the history of the revolution.
Rectification is finding the way to resolve errors that are hundreds of years
old.” (“Alert on Before Night Falls,” Jon Hillson)
That same year, Cuba’s National Commission on Sex Education stated that
homosexuality is a sexual orientation and announced the goal of countering
homophobia with education. (From the film “Gay Cuba”)
In 1988, Fidel Castro spoke out publicly about the need to change negative
attitudes in society and in the party about homosexuality.
At the 1992 congress of the Union of Young Communists, Cuban revolutionary
leader Vilma Espín, president of the Federation of Cuban Women (FMC),
challenged prejudicial ideas presented by a psychologist. Sonia de Vries,
director of the film “Gay Cuba,” reported that Espín stated
that what needed changing was prejudice, not gay and lesbian sexuality. (Cuba
Update)
That same year, Fidel Castro stated in an interview: “I am absolutely
opposed to any form of repression, contempt, scorn or discrimination with
regard to homosexuals. [It is] a natural human tendency that must simply be
respected.”
These qualitative changes in Cuba, like still photographs, capture the peaks of
progress.
The release of three films in the 1990s—”Strawberry and
Chocolate,” “Gay Cuba” and “Butterflies on the
Scaffold”—offered a panoramic moving picture of the sweep of
progress resulting from decades of the process of building socialism despite
the imperialist military, economic and political blockade.
From the balcony to the screen
When Havana was ruled by U.S. crime bosses and bankers, capitalism made room in
the market for homosexual acts, forced to serve the fantasies of those who
could afford the cost in dollars and pesos. Often the patricians who paid for
sex despised those whom they exploited—hating them for their class, their
race, their sex and/or their gender expression and for witnessing the cruelty,
self-hatred, guilt and shame in the customers’ desires.
So there were lots of homosexual acts taking place in Havana—the biggest
U.S. brothel industry in the Caribbean. But off the clock there was not much
social room for two men or two women of any gender expression to meet and get
to know each other, to freely follow same-sex attraction and exploration, or to
fall in love and/or live together as couples or in other formations.
Many men found each other in the darkened theaters of old Cuban cinemas like
the Campoamor, Rialto and Verdún. One older Cuban homosexual recalled,
“[Y]ou could go and immediately pick up a young guy. Many had their first
experience there. There was a lot of sex in those cinemas.” (Lumsden)
The culture of Cuba changed with social ownership of the means of production on
the island—the land, mines, factories and other major arteries of
economic life.
The Cuban Revolution did not, and could not, wave a magic wand and instantly
transform the social content of culture. But it quickly transformed the
economic underpinnings of culture. Like everything else that is collectively
produced on the island, culture began to be produced to meet the social needs
of the many, not just packaged for individual consumption for the few.
Lumsden, who published his views on Cuba in 1996, reported the ways in which he
saw culture being made available to everyone in Cuba. “This is evident in
the low prices and range of theater, dance and music that are available on
stage or in open spaces like the Parque Central in Old Havana. It is evident in
the quantity and quality of translated foreign and domestic books that have
been published at low prices in huge editions. Finally it is evident in events
such as the annual film festival (New Latin American Cinema), which has an
impact as great as Toronto’s Festival.” (Temple University
Press)
Lumsden observed: “When you attend a cultural event in Havana you come
away as impressed by the informed and critical engagement of the audience as
you are by the innovative quality of the performance itself. This involvement
is far removed from the commodified nature of so many mainstream cultural
events in North America.”
This is the Cuban audience that flocked to the state-sponsored release of the
1993 blockbuster movie “Strawberry and Chocolate.” The film, about
an attempt at friendship and understanding between a young heterosexual
communist and a homosexual, brought same-sex love out of the cinema balconies,
where shame and guilt lurked in the shadows, and onto the silver screen of
Cuban culture.
Over the next two years, two important documentaries followed—“Gay
Cuba” in 1994 and “Butterflies on the Scaffold” in 1995.
All told, these movies offer a view of the influence of revolutionary process
on popular culture, as well as the influence of popular culture on
revolutionary development. The films are themselves part of that dialectical
struggle, which itself takes place within the battle against the roar of ruling
imperialist ideology, broadcast at every turn by its entertainment, media and
education industries.
Next: “Strawberry and Chocolate,” sweet taste of
change.
To find out more about Cuba, read parts 86-101 of Lavender & Red
at workers.org.
E-mail: lfeinberg.org
Articles copyright 1995-2012 Workers World.
Verbatim copying and distribution of this entire article is permitted in any medium without royalty provided this notice is preserved.
Workers World, 55 W. 17 St., NY, NY 10011
Email:
[email protected]
Subscribe
[email protected]
Support independent news
DONATE