Tony Dungy, Lovie Smith make Super Bowl history
Published Feb 6, 2007 9:20 PM
Lovie Smith, left, and Tony Dungy embrace
after Super Bowl Feb. 4.
Black history and sports history were made on Feb. 4 when two African-American
professional football head coaches, Tony Dungy of the Indianapolis Colts and
Lovie Smith of the Chicago Bears, led their teams to the most popular one-day
sports event in the U.S. and one of the most popular worldwide—the Super
The Super Bowl is the showdown between the winner of the National Football
Conference and the winner of the American Football Conference to determine the
champion of the National Football League.
Until now, the most significant Super Bowl since its inception in 1967—in
terms of social significance—was in 1988, when Doug Williams became the
first Black quarterback to play in a Super Bowl. He also won the Most Valuable
Now Dungy has become the first Black head coach to ever win the Super Bowl as
the Colts defeated the Bears by the score of 29-17 in Miami. Dungy, the prior
head coach of the Tampa Bay Buccaneers, gave Smith his first job as an
assistant coach. Dungy’s Colts coaching staff is half people of
The sight of the two coaches embracing at the end of Super Bowl XLI was
captured by media all around the world. Smith told the media after the game
that if he couldn’t win the Super Bowl, he would have wanted Dungy to win
based on their personal relationship and the fact that Dungy is Black.
Racism and sports
This year, 2007, will mark the 60th anniversary of the great Jackie Robinson,
an African American, breaking the color barrier of Major League Baseball, a
feat that challenged white supremacy in other areas of sports and U.S. society
as a whole before the Civil Rights movement took root in the South.
This year also marks the 20th anniversary of when the former Los Angeles
Dodgers General Manager Al Campanis made the racist statement that Black people
“may not have some of the necessities” to become managers of
College and professional football was integrated long before Robinson signed
with the Brooklyn Dodgers in 1947. MLB, however, was a more popular and
prestigious sport at the time, being dubbed as “America’s
When Robinson was asked to play in an old-timers game following his retirement,
he refused, stating, “I must sorrowfully refuse until I see more progress
being made off the playing field on the coaching lines and in the managerial
Football has gained more popularity over the decades, especially with the
influence of TV. Today, the NFL players are at least 70 percent African
American but up until Super Bowl XLI, there are still only six Black head
coaches out of 32—besides Dungy and Smith, there are Herman Edwards,
Marvin Lewis, Romeo Crennell and the recently hired Mike Tomlin. Smith is
currently the lowest paid coach in the entire NFL.
This gross disparity should raise the question: Why aren’t at least 70
percent of the NFL head coaches Black? This goal could be met with a
NFL-sponsored coaches’ training program especially for Black people and
other people of color who have been systematically denied this opportunity.
When it comes to executive positions in the NFL, the numbers are even more
dismal. There are only three Black general managers and no Black owners.
The increase in Black NFL coaches did not come about out of any anti-racist
consciousness on the part of the majority white owners. Back in 2002, the late
Black lawyer Johnnie Cochran and another lawyer, Cyrus Mehri, threatened to
bring a lawsuit against the NFL for racial discrimination in their hiring
practices. At that time, there were only two Black head coaches in the NFL.
The impending lawsuit forced the NFL to implement the “Rooney
rule,” named after Pittsburgh Steelers’ owner, Art Rooney. This
rule states that for every head coach vacancy, NFL owners must interview,
although not necessarily hire, at least one person of color for the job. Rooney
just hired Mike Tomlin for the Steelers’ new coaching job.
Bomani Jones wrote for ESPN.com regarding the NFL, “There is nothing
worth celebrating about a league that has to force its franchises to interview
nonwhite coaching candidates and finally has a black coach in the 41st edition
of its biggest game. That’s not a good thing. That’s a damn
In National Collegiate Athletic Association football, amongst 119 Division One
teams, there are only six Black head coaches, where 50 percent of these NCAA
players are Black. (mercurynews.com)
The achievements of Tony Dungy and Lovie Smith not only signaled a great
historical leap forward but also show how much farther the NFL has to go to
strengthen affirmative action, including quotas, when it comes to hiring more
coaches of color.
Racist profiling in sports is as pervasive under capitalist U.S. society as
police brutality, and only a struggle from below can turn the situation
Articles copyright 1995-2012 Workers World.
Verbatim copying and distribution of this entire article is permitted in any medium without royalty provided this notice is preserved.
Workers World, 55 W. 17 St., NY, NY 10011
Support independent news DONATE