FREE THEM NOW!
Lesbians sentenced for self-defense
All-white jury convicts Black women
Published Jun 21, 2007 2:58 AM
On June 14, four African-American women—Venice Brown (19), Terrain
Dandridge (20), Patreese Johnson (20) and Renata Hill (24)—received
sentences ranging from three-and-a-half to 11 years in prison. None of them had
previous criminal records. Two of them are parents of small children.
Their crime? Defending themselves from a physical attack by a man who held them
down and choked them, ripped hair from their scalps, spat on them, and
threatened to sexually assault them—all because they are lesbians.
The mere fact that any victim of a bigoted attack would be arrested, jailed and
then convicted for self-defense is an outrage. But the length of prison time
given further demonstrates the highly political nature of this case and just
how racist, misogynistic, anti-gay, anti-youth and anti-worker the so-called
U.S. justice system truly is.
The description of the events, reported below, is based on written statements
by a community organization (FIERCE) that has made a call to action to defend
the four women, verbal accounts from court observers and evidence from a
On Aug. 16, 2006, seven young, African-American, lesbian-identified friends
were walking in the West Village. The Village is a historic center for lesbian,
gay, bi and trans (LGBT) communities, and is seen as a safe haven for
working-class LGBT youth, especially youth of color.
As they passed the Independent Film Cinema, 29-year-old Dwayne Buckle, an
African-American vendor selling DVDs, sexually propositioned one of the women.
They rebuffed his advances and kept walking.
“I’ll f— you straight, sweetheart!” Buckle shouted. A
video camera from a nearby store shows the women walking away. He followed
them, all the while hurling anti-lesbian slurs, grabbing his genitals and
making explicitly obscene remarks. The women finally stopped and confronted
him. A heated argument ensued. Buckle spat in the face of one of the women and
threw his lit cigarette at them, escalating the verbal attack into a physical
Buckle is seen on the video grabbing and pulling out large patches of hair from
one of the young women. When Buckle ended up on top of one of the women,
choking her, Johnson pulled a small steak knife out of her purse. She aimed for
his arm to stop him from killing her friend.
The video captures two men finally running over to help the women and beating
Buckle. At some point he was stabbed in the abdomen. The women were already
walking away across the street by the time the police arrived.
Buckle was hospitalized for five days after surgery for a lacerated liver and
stomach. When asked at the hospital, he responded at least twice that men had
There was no evidence that Johnson’s kitchen knife was the weapon that
penetrated his abdomen, nor was there any blood visible on it. In fact, there
was never any forensics testing done on her knife. On the night they were
arrested, the police told the women that there would be a search by the New
York Police Department for the two men—which to date has not
After almost a year of trial, four of the seven were convicted in April.
Johnson was sentenced to 11 years on June 14.
Even with Buckle’s admission and the video footage proving that he
instigated this anti-gay attack, the women were relentlessly demonized in the
press, had trumped-up felony charges levied against them, and were subsequently
given long sentences in order to send a clear resounding message—that
self-defense is a crime and no one should dare to fight back.
Political backdrop of the case
Why were these young women used as an example? At stake are the billions of
dollars in tourism and real estate development involved in the continued
gentrification of the West Village. This particular incident happened near the
Washington Square area—home of New York University, one of most expensive
private colleges in the country and one of the biggest employers and landlords
in New York City. The New York Times reported that Justice Edward J. McLaughlin
used his sentencing speech to comment on “how New York welcomes
tourists.” (June 17)
The Village is also the home of the Stonewall Rebellion, the three-day street
battle against the NYPD that, along with the Compton Cafeteria
“Riots” in California, helped launch the modern-day LGBT liberation
movement in 1969. The Manhattan LGBT Pride march, one of the biggest
demonstrations of LGBT peoples in the world, ends near the Christopher Street
Piers in the Village, which have been the historical “hangout” and
home for working-class trans and LGBT youth in New York City for decades.
Because of growing gentrification in recent years, young people of color,
homeless and transgender communities, LGBT and straight, have faced curfews and
brutality by police sanctioned by the West Village community board and
politicians. On Oct. 31, 2006, police officers from the NYPD’s 6th
Precinct indiscriminately beat and arrested several people of color in sweeps
on Christopher Street after the Halloween parade.
Since the 1980s there has been a steady increase in anti-LGBT violence in the
area, with bashers going there with that purpose in mind.
For trans people and LGBT youth of color, who statistically experience higher
amounts of bigoted violence, the impact of the gentrification has been severe.
As their once-safe haven is encroached on by real estate developers, the new
white and majority heterosexual residents of the West Village then call in the
state to brutalize them.
For the last six years the political LGBT youth group FIERCE has been at the
forefront of mobilizing young people “to counter the displacement and
criminalization of LGBTSTQ [lesbian, gay, bi, two spirit, trans, and queer]
youth of color and homeless youth at the Christopher Street Pier and in
Manhattan’s West Village.” (www.fiercenyc.org) FIERCE has also been
the lead organization supporting the Jersey Seven and their families.
The trial and the media
Deemed a so-called “hate crime” against a straight man, every
possible racist, anti-woman, anti-LGBT and anti-youth tactic was used by the
entire state apparatus and media. Everything from the fact that they lived
outside of New York, in the working-class majority Black city of Newark, N.J.,
to their gender expressions and body structures were twisted and dehumanized in
the public eye and to the jury.
According to court observers, McLaughlin stated throughout the trial that he
had no sympathy for these women. The jury, although they were all women, were
all white. All witnesses for the district attorney were white men, except for
one Black male who had several felony charges.
Court observers report that the defense attorneys had to put enormous effort
into simply convincing the jury that they were “average women” who
had planned to just hang out together that night. Some jurists asked why they
were in the Village if they were from New Jersey. The DA brought up whether
they could afford to hang out there—raising the issue of who has the
right to be there in the first place.
The Daily News reporting was relentless in its racist anti-lesbian misogyny,
portraying Buckle as a “filmmaker” and “sound engineer”
preyed upon by a “lesbian wolf pack” (April 19) and a “gang
of angry lesbians.” (April 13)
Everyone has been socialized by cultural archetypes of what it means to be a
“man” or “masculine” and “woman” or
“feminine.” Gender identity/expression is the way each indivdual
chooses or not to express gender in their everyday lives, including how they
dress, walk, talk, etc. Transgender people and other gender non-conforming
people face oppression based on their gender expression/identity.
The only pictures shown in the Daily News were of the more masculine-appearing
women. One of the most despiciable headlines in the Daily News,
“‘I’m a man!’ lesbian growled during fight,”
(April 13) was targeted against Renata Hill, who was taunted by Buckle because
of her masculinity.
Ironically, Johnson, who was singled out by the judge as the
“ringleader,” is the more feminine of the four. According to the
New York Times, in his sentencing remarks, “Justice McLaughlin scoffed at
the assertion made by ... Johnson, that she carried a knife because she was
just 4-foot-11 and 95 pounds, worked nights and lived in a dangerous
neighborhood.” He quoted the nursery rhyme, “Sticks and stones will
break my bones, but names will never hurt me.” (June 15)
All of the seven women knew and went to school with Sakia Gunn, a 19-year-old
butch lesbian who was stabbed to death in Newark, N.J., in May 2003.
Paralleling the present case, Gunn was out with three of her friends when a man
made sexual advances to one of the women. When she replied that she was a
lesbian and not interested, he attacked them. Gunn fought back and was stabbed
“You can’t help but wonder that if Sakia Gunn had a weapon, would
she be in jail right now?” Bran Fenner, a founding member and
co-executive director of FIERCE, told Workers World. “If we don’t
have the right to self-defense, how are we supposed to survive?”
National call to action
While racist killer cops continue to go without indictment and anti-immigrant
paramilitary groups like the Minutemen are on the rise in the U.S., The Jersey
Four sit behind bars for simply defending themselves against a bigot who
attacked them in the Village.
Capitalism at its very core is a racist, sexist, anti-LGBT system, sanctioning
state violence through cops, courts and its so-called laws. The case of the
Jersey Four gives more legal precedence for bigoted violence to go
unchallenged. The ruling class saw this case as a political one; FIERCE and
other groups believe the entire progressive movement should as well.
Fenner said, “We are organizing in the hope that this wakes up all
oppressed people and sparks a huge, broad campaign to demand freedom for the
FIERCE is asking for assistance for these young women, including pro-bono legal
support, media contacts and writers, pen pals, financial support, and diverse
organizational support. For details, visit www.fiercenyc.org.
Articles copyright 1995-2012 Workers World.
Verbatim copying and distribution of this entire article is permitted in any medium without royalty provided this notice is preserved.
Workers World, 55 W. 17 St., NY, NY 10011
Email: [email protected]
Subscribe [email protected]
Support independent news DONATE