Early resistance to state repression
Lesbian, gay, bi and trans pride series part 29
Published Mar 23, 2005 1:39 PM
In the inhospitable social climate of the
Cold War, struggles were taking root in the U.S. that would later flower in the
gay and trans liberation movement of the late 1960s.
How was it possible,
some may wonder today, for gays to have resisted and organized in the 1940s and
1950s when state repression and a reactionary ideological offensive were at
In the war between exploiter and exploited, oppressor and
oppressed, the relationship of forces may change many times, but those under
siege never cease to find ways to struggle for their freedom.
Much of the
history of the struggle for homosexual and gender and women’s rights in
the decades of greatest political repression has been buried under the
reactionary weight of the Cold War propaganda machine. Under standing how the
early stirrings of the homophile movement of the 1940s and 1950s began serves to
arm today’s movement, which has much greater opportunities for resistance
against political reaction.
Also, the 1969 Stonewall Rebellion and the
mass political wave of struggle it unleashed can seem almost accidental or
episodic without a general overview of the acts of resistance and attempts to
organize that preceded the four-night-long uprising.
The choice of
language to describe these earlier decades is difficult. Similar words may be
used to describe sex, love and affection with regard to different historical
periods, economic classes, nationalities, ethnicities and regions. However, the
ways people saw themselves and each other and the ways medical authorities,
police, courts and military brass categorized and criminalized people and their
behaviors have undergone many changes.
The world of same-sex love among
many blue-collar and oppressed people in the first half of the century in the
U.S. was intertwined with gender and sex variance—or what today might be
referred to as transgender and transsexual. It’s also hard to separate
bisexuality from the exclusive expression of same-sex love in early periods.
Here “LGBT” will be used, not to stamp the past with a modern
acronym that has come to symbolize a united front coalition of sexuality, gender
and sex minorities, but to show the inability to parse the population into
Centralizing force of capitalism
rise of the 1940s and 1950s homophile movement itself is hard to fathom without
taking into account the awakening of LGBT people in the 1920s and 1930s.
Material developments in life under capitalism made this not only possible in
those early decades of the 20th century, but necessary.
By the end of the
19th century, Northern industrial capital and banking had consolidated its
victory over the Southern slave-owning landed aristocracy. The overturning of
Black Reconstruction through lynch “law” and Jim Crow fascist
conditions had brought a violent end to an unfinished revolution. This created
huge shifts in the population from agriculture to urban areas in search of jobs.
In these vast, anonymous cities and port towns, with same-sex boarding houses
and parks and piers, nascent LGBT subcultures took shape.
unable to satiate its hunger for profits through domestic expansion alone,
emerged as an imperialist power, exporting war for empire and profits to Cuba,
Puerto Rico and the Philippines in 1898. A decade and a half later the
world’s imperialist powers dragged the workers into a gory struggle over
redividing the world’s colonies in the first World War.
military deployment and wartime industry also pulled massive numbers of women
and men from rural areas, small towns and cities into same-sex living conditions
and new social conditions that broke down the old order.
workers’ revolution that scared the imperialists into finally ending the
war. The Cold War really began in the U.S. after the workers and peasants of
Russia rose up in the 1917 Bolshevik Revolution and established the first
lasting workers’ state. The revolution reverberated around the globe,
lifting the heads of laboring and oppressed peoples in every part of the
The communist government in Russia immediately struck down the
anti-homosexual laws. In the U.S., however, the capitalist government made LGBT
people one of the early targets of repression, along with communists,
anarchists, trade unionists and immigrants.
In the spring of 1919, the brass at the Newport Naval Training
Center covertly sent a group of young enlisted men into the base and the nearby
community to lure “sexual perverts” and bring back evidence about
After entrapment had provided the
necessary “evidence,” naval and municipal officials rounded up more
than 20 sailors and 16 civilians. They faced naval and civilian trials.
was one thing when the dragnet ensnared enlisted sailors, mostly from the
working class. But when a prominent minister from the Episcopal Church of
Newport got caught in the nets, and civilian and later military officials forced
him to stand trial, all hell broke loose.
“Protests by the Newport
Ministerial Union and the Episcopal Bishop of Rhode Island and a vigorous
editorial campaign by the Providence Journal forced the Navy to conduct a second
inquiry in 1920 into the methods used in the first investigation,”
historian George Chauncey Jr. wrote.
“When the inquiry criticized
the methods but essentially exonerated the senior naval officers who had
instituted them, the ministers asked the Republican-controlled Senate Naval
Affairs Committee to conduct its own investigation.”
Republicans agreed, eager to attack the Democratic administration.
Senate committee issued its report in 1921. It exonerated the minister. Although
the report, Chauncey noted, “expressed deep anti-homosexual loathing, it
condemned the conduct of the highest naval officials involved, including
Franklin D. Roosevelt, President Wilson’s Assistant Secretary of the Navy
and the 1920 Democratic vice-presidential candidate.” (“Homosexual
Identities and the Construction of Sexual Boundaries in the World War I
Smoke, lilies and jade
The mass migrations to
large cities, port towns and military bases in the 1920s and 1930s had created
the basis for larger and more concentrated subcultures.
evidence that LGBT life flourished more in the first third of the 20th century,
particularly in the 1920s and 1930s, than it did after World War II.
described same-sex love and gender variance in New York, one of the capitals of
LGBT life, as “a working-class world, center ed in African American and
Irish and Italian immigrant neighborhoods and along the city’s busy
waterfront, and drawing on the social forms of working-class culture.”
The most visible, organized and eloquent LGBT expression in the pre-World
War II era came from the Black movement in the United States.
As the Great
Migration from the South to the North burgeoned into Black urban capitals, LGBT
expression became a part of their histories.
Thousands attended LGBT
balls in Harlem, Chicago, Baltimore and Wash ing ton, D.C., which were widely
reported on in Black community newspapers.
In New York the balls were held
at the Rockland Palace, the Astor Hotel and Mad ison Square Garden. The most
famous was the annual Hamilton Lodge Ball in Har lem, which dated back to 1879.
The majority of those who attended were working class. About 800 took part in
1925; 1,500 in 1937. Attendance peaked at 8,000 in 1937 before police raids shut
Harlem was the heart of one of the great cultural and political
high-water marks of U.S. history—the Harlem Renaissance—which ran
from the end of World War I in 1918 until the capitalist depression.
flowering of literature, art, music and political organizing—all of which
was influenced by aspirations for national liberation and hope for an end to
dreams deferred, sparked by the socialist revolution in Russia—also gave
voice to LGBT concerns.
Richard Bruce Nugent, a self-identified gay man,
published the classic “Smoke, Lilies and Jade” in 1926. It was the
first known work by a Black author clearly about same-sex love. He said about
LGBT life in Harlem during that period, “Nobody was in the closet. There
wasn’t any closets.”
Next: German Homosexual Emancipation
Movement inspired 1920s U.S. organizing.
Articles copyright 1995-2012 Workers World.
Verbatim copying and distribution of this entire article is permitted in any medium without royalty provided this notice is preserved.
Workers World, 55 W. 17 St., NY, NY 10011
Support independent news DONATE